answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Piggy states that the other boys have deserted them, "Just for some meat ----" Ralph adds the following reasons for the other boys defection to Jack, I quote, "And for the hunting, " said Ralph, wisely, "and for pretending to be a tribe, and putting on war-paint."

User Avatar

Wiki User

15y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

In an attempt to reconcile with them, or possibly reasoning "If you can't beat them, join them."

Piggy suffered from myopia or nearsightedness and needed his glasses for vision but jack and his crew stole it and were at their fort.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

9y ago

In chapter 9, Ralph said: '"And for hunting," said Ralph, wisely, "and for pretending to be a tribe, and putting on war-paint."' (Golding, pg.163). Jack lures the boys in to his control by offering them meat from his hunts, and excitement. Jack is a manipulative leader who can insert fear in the boys; while the boys are scared and overwhelmed by emotional instincts, Jack takes the opportunity to persuade the boys. He also uses effective traps by not telling the boys that he will not completely control them. Ralph, at this point, realizes the need for order and organization; he knows that they can no longer act like children. Although he wants civilization and order in the boys, he has difficulty communicating to the boys. Jack, on the other hand, can foresee the boys' fears and instincts, therefore being able to control and brainwash them.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago

He is the only one left in his tribe, and he knows that Jack's tribe wants to kill him.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

they were being "hunted off" so they thought that they needed to go make sure that the beast did not exist. and that it was someone amongst themselves killing them.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

Jack did not actually leave the tribe. He formed his own "tribe" because he was tired of following Ralph's rules.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What reason does Ralph give for the boys defection to jack lotf?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about TV & Celebs

What reason does Ralph give for the boys' defection to Jack?

In chapter 9, Ralph said: '"And for hunting," said Ralph, wisely, "and for pretending to be a tribe, and putting on war-paint."' (Golding, pg.163). Jack lures the boys in to his control by offering them meat from his hunts, and excitement. Jack is a manipulative leader who can insert fear in the boys; while the boys are scared and overwhelmed by emotional instincts, Jack takes the opportunity to persuade the boys. He also uses effective traps by not telling the boys that he will not completely control them. Ralph, at this point, realizes the need for order and organization; he knows that they can no longer act like children. Although he wants civilization and order in the boys, he has difficulty communicating to the boys. Jack, on the other hand, can foresee the boys' fears and instincts, therefore being able to control and brainwash them.


What job does Ralph give piggy?

To take the names of the boys


What excuses does Ralph give to let Piggy stay behind when the other boys go?

To watch over the young kids.


Why do the boys taunt Piggy?

Ralph doesn't actually ever give up being chief but after the meeting in chapter 5: Beast from Water breaks up and he fears that the boys would ignore him if he blows the conch Ralph considers the possibility. He says, and I quote, "I ought to give up being chief. Hear 'em." Piggy is totally dismayed and gripping ralph's arm tells him that, "If Jack was chief he'd have all hunting and no fire. we'd be here till we died." Simon reinforced Piggys remarks by saying "Piggy's right, Ralph. there's you and Jack. Go on being chief."


What could Ralph have done differently in the lord of the flies?

Nothing and that is the point of the novel. All of the boys, Ralph included, eventually give in to their innate savagery through time as they gradually lose the influence of the old society of morals and regulations and descend into corruption and savagery innate in human nature without the restraint of society. Ralph did simply everything he could given the deteriorating situation, trying to implement law and civility into the boys but his efforts were lost in the frenzy of the innate savagery emerging from themselves. As we see towards the end of the novel, even Ralph forgets the importance and hope of the fire signal and participates in a hunt and is involved in the murder of Simon. They were helpless to themselves.

Related questions

What reason does Ralph give for the boys' defection of jack?

That he knows he is strong enough to hunt


What reason does Ralph give for the boys' defection to Jack?

In chapter 9, Ralph said: '"And for hunting," said Ralph, wisely, "and for pretending to be a tribe, and putting on war-paint."' (Golding, pg.163). Jack lures the boys in to his control by offering them meat from his hunts, and excitement. Jack is a manipulative leader who can insert fear in the boys; while the boys are scared and overwhelmed by emotional instincts, Jack takes the opportunity to persuade the boys. He also uses effective traps by not telling the boys that he will not completely control them. Ralph, at this point, realizes the need for order and organization; he knows that they can no longer act like children. Although he wants civilization and order in the boys, he has difficulty communicating to the boys. Jack, on the other hand, can foresee the boys' fears and instincts, therefore being able to control and brainwash them.


What job does Ralph give piggy?

To take the names of the boys


What excuses does Ralph give to let Piggy stay behind when the other boys go?

To watch over the young kids.


What happens to samneric during the confrontation?

During the confrontation in "Lord of the Flies," Samneric betray Ralph's trust and align themselves with Jack's tribe. They give away Ralph's hiding place to the other boys, leading to Ralph being hunted like prey. Ultimately, Samneric are forced to participate in the hunt for Ralph against their will.


Did Sam and Eric give up Ralph's hiding place to Jack?

Yes, Sam and Eric did reveal Ralph's hiding place to Jack's tribe out of fear and pressure from the other boys. This act ultimately led to Ralph's capture and near-death experience in "Lord of the Flies" by William Golding.


What Ralph piggy and Simon respectively say about beasts?

Ralph believes the beast is not real and only a figment of the boys' imaginations, while Piggy sees the beast as a symbol of the boys' inner fears and darkness. Simon, on the other hand, suggests that the beast might actually be the innate evil within each of them that grows stronger as they give in to their primal instincts.


What reason does b wordsworth give for wanting to come into the boys yard?

B Wordsworth mentions that he is attracted to the boys and wants to play with them. He feels a sense of nostalgia and longing for the joy and innocence that children possess.


Why do boys have to have a bellybutton?

For the same reason that girls do. When babies are in the mother's womb the umbilical cord is connected to the baby's belly button to give it nourishment.


In lord of the flies after Simon is killed who remains on Ralph's side?

He runs to them screaming "BEAST", so they mistake him for the beast, and stab him with their spears. He dies.


Why does the conch give Ralph so much power in lord of the slies book?

In "Lord of the Flies," the conch symbolizes order, civilization, and democracy. When Ralph blows the conch, it gathers the boys together, giving him a platform to establish rules and maintain order. The conch's power comes from the boys' collective agreement to respect it as a symbol of authority and civilization.


Why is Ralph considering giving up leadership?

Ralph is considering giving up leadership because he is feeling overwhelmed by the responsibility and the challenges of maintaining order and unity among the group. He is also struggling to deal with the growing fear and division among the boys, particularly with Jack's increasing power and influence.