0
This is a question asking for an opinion. As a result, you may find dissenting views.
Answer 1: Yes - Because of the War of the Ring
Long and metaphorical answer: Yes, because everything happens for a reason, even if we do not see why at the time. For example, if Thorin had not died but become King Under the Mountain, then Dain would not have become king. Many years later in the War of the Ring, the dwarves would have fought with different strategy. This would mean that the end results would be different, possibly meaning that the orc armies sent to fight in the North would have been in Mordor and would have caught Frodo. Then, the ring would never have been destroyed and the fate of all Middle Earth would be completely changed.
So bottom line, yes, his death is necessary.
Answer 2: Yes - External Mirror to Internal Corruption
A very important theme in The Hobbit is the corrupting power of incredible wealth. The wealth of Erebor corrupts Thorin as it had corrupted Kings Thror and Thrain before him, rotting his soul. His mortal wounds in the Battle of Five Armies make his exterior mirror his interior and brings about the reconciliation between him and Bilbo. If Thorin had lived, it is likely that the clarity he achieved would not have come. Additionally, the ascension of Dain II Ironfoot allowed for a new relationship to develop between the Elves of Mirkwood and the Men of the rebuilt City of Dale on a very different page than how Thorin had left those relationships.
As for Answer 1, even if Thorin had led a different strategy to defend Erebor in the War of the Ring, it is inconceivable that Thorin would have accepted the Dark Lord's offer of Union. Thus, it would be requisite for Sauron to send an army to the North, even if that battle had gone differently. As a result, the reasons discussing the War of the Ring are unsupportable.
Answer 3: No
As the author Tolkien had the power to write Thorin in such a way as for him not to die. Not much else happens in the narrative after his passing and there are no things that Dain does that Thorin could not have done instead. Is it more poetic that Thorin dies defending "his gold" than in pursuing it, certainly, but it is not necessary.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Are fili and Kili brothers?
Indeed they are. Fili is the older and more responsible one, whereas Kili is more carefree and does not feel the pressure of royalty as much as his older brother. Fili and Kili were both born of Dis, Thorin Oakenshield's sister. So, to Thorin, they are his sister-sons, and to Fili and Kili, Thorin is their uncle. They became rather close to Thorin, who became their idol, and developed a thirst to impress him.
Who is ori from The Hobbit?
Ori was a Dwarf that appears in The Hobbit: Unexpected Journey. Ori usually wore a grey-hooded cloak with a Silver belt when traveling abroad. He also plays the flute. He is also, along with his brothers Dori and Nori part of Thorin Oakenshields company
Who led the dwarves after Thorin's death?
Dain Ironfoot King Under the Mountain inherited the throne from Thorin Oakenshield after he died in the Battle of the Five Armies. He led the Dwarves from the time of the events in the Hobbit until Sauron's Attack on Erebor (which was concurrent with the Siege of Minas Tirith in Gondor).
What does Thorin vow to do to anyone who withholds the Arkenstone?
Thorin vows to kill anyone who withholds the Arkenstone .
Who are the ancestors of Thorin Oakenshield?
Thorin Oakenshield, son of Thrain, son of Thror, King Under the Mountain.
Are fili and Kili brothers?
Indeed they are. Fili is the older and more responsible one, whereas Kili is more carefree and does not feel the pressure of royalty as much as his older brother. Fili and Kili were both born of Dis, Thorin Oakenshield's sister. So, to Thorin, they are his sister-sons, and to Fili and Kili, Thorin is their uncle. They became rather close to Thorin, who became their idol, and developed a thirst to impress him.
Who is ori from The Hobbit?
Ori was a Dwarf that appears in The Hobbit: Unexpected Journey. Ori usually wore a grey-hooded cloak with a Silver belt when traveling abroad. He also plays the flute. He is also, along with his brothers Dori and Nori part of Thorin Oakenshields company
What does Thorin offer Baggins as a reward for his a assistance?
One fourteenth share in the profits, expenses, and funeral expenses (if necessary).nothing
When was Thorin born?
Jeffrey Thorin was born in 1961.
What was the gold chain that Gandalf gave to Thorin?
{| |- | Gandalf did not give Thorin a gold chain. Gandalf gave Thorin the key that he had gotten from Thorin's father. Thorin then took the key and placed it on a gold chain that he was wearing around his neck. |}
Where is Thorin located?
Thorin is not a place, he is a dwarf, son of Thror.
When was Thorin Oakenshield created?
Thorin Oakenshield was created in 1937.
When did Olof Thorin die?
Olof Thorin died in 2004.
When was Jeffrey Thorin born?
Jeffrey Thorin was born in 1961.
Where did thorin get the key to open the door?
Thorin's father, Thrain, gave the key to Gandalf, who gave it to Thorin
Are Bilbo and Thorin related?
No they are not. Bilbo is simple hobbit from the Shire, Thorin is a dwarf.
Why did thorin rekindle his friendship with Bilbo before he died?
Thorin rekindled his friendship with Bilbo before he died because he realized the importance of their bond and the loyalty and bravery Bilbo had shown during their journey. Additionally, Thorin recognized that Bilbo's actions were instrumental in their success, and he wanted to make amends for his earlier distrust and mistreatment of Bilbo. Finally, Thorin's impending death also likely prompted him to seek reconciliation and closure with Bilbo before it was too late.
