Is Breaking Dawn appropriate for 11 year old girls?

Answer 1

Some say it is appropriate and some say it isn't. I would read it yourself to find out if you think it is or is not appropriate for 11 year olds. P.S. It also depends on how mature he / she is!!! - Jamerinsky, Have a good day!

Answer 2

Well depending on how old you are I would say its appropriate for any one 10 or up. The parts that most people would call inappropriate are not in much detail so personally i don't know why everyone is getting all angry about it.

Hope this helped you. :)

Well, This book has some mild Sexual Content. Nothing Big. Mostly depends on how mature you are. Also you can have a parent read this first if you are concerned.

Answer 3

I am 11 and I have read Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse. My mom isn't sure whether to let me read Breaking Dawn or not. But, after you read the first three books, its impossible not to want to read the book! A friend of mine has read all four. She said there are some sex scenes in the book, but Stephenie Meyer isn't too detailed or graphic...I wouldn't be surprised if they didn't know what was going on at all! Kissing scenes are totally ok for 11 year old girls, trust me! Sometimes, it depends on the maturity level of the girl and if you trust her. If your still not ok with it, I would suggest you read the book before she does, just to make sure it is ok. Most say 12-13 should read it, but I'm 11 and so far I've handled it. I think 11 is fine if you know she is mature.

It all depends on whether you think your daughter, sister, friend, etc. will be able to handle it or if they will be uncomfortable. As the person before me said, it depends on the reader's maturity level. If you are okay with him/her reading the book, then go ahead and let them read.

My sister is 19 and she read it, but I am 11, and my mom says "no" I dont know aanyone who has, but I agree with you there, there is a sex scene, and there almost is in Eclipse. I read Twilight- Eclipse, and soon I wanna read Breaking Dawn, hopefully my mom will let me!

* * *

I am 12, but I read the books when i was 11. I have read all four. There are sex scenes in Breaking dawn but, Stephenie Meyer does not go into detail. Infact she doesn't even write that their having sex, it just goes on to another day. I think it's good anyway as it's good learning experience and if they are mature, why not?

Answer 4

I think that breaking dawn is appropriate for 12 and over. I am 13 and I have read it and it has a good plot. But it has them having sex and Bella giving birth but the book doesn't describe it very much. I hope that answers your question.

Answer 5

I honestly think that depends on your child. If you think they are mature enough to handle it them sure.

But both the movie and book deal with more mature content that goes along with being in love and getting married. I personally read the book in the fifth grade when I was eleven years old but prior to reading it my mom and I discussed the content and she made sure I was able to understand. I think that if you're okay with letting your child read the book Breaking Dawn then the movie is fine.

Their actually isn't much sex shown in the movie and none of the actors private areas are shown so it really isn't that bad. But it was a great movie.

Hope that helps.

Answer 6

the book yes, but the movie won't be