0
Ice is considered a mineral because it is a solid with a defined chemical composition (H2O) and a crystalline structure. Water, on the other hand, is a liquid that does not possess a fixed geometric arrangement of molecules like a mineral.
Ice is a mineral because it fits all the criteria of being a mineral. It's solid, inorganic, crystalline, naturally occurring, and has a well defined chemical composition. I bet you're wondering if liquid water is a mineral. It's not a mineral, because it's not solid or crystalline.
Ice is a mineral because it meets the requirements of being a mineral.
- naturally occurring (not made by humans)
- inorganic (not produced by an organism)
- solid
- a limited range of chemical compositions
- ordered atomic structure
http://geology.com/articles/water-mineral/
Scientists consider ice a mineral because it is a solid, it has a crystalline structure, it comes naturally (water) ,and it is inorgantic (not made from living things EX:paper).
Ice is a recognized mineral, meeting the requirements of the definition: solid, naturally occurring, definite chemical formula, crystalline structure, and inorganic.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why is ice in a glacier consider to be a mineral but water from a glacier is not?
By definition a mineral must be solid. Ice is solid. Water is not.
Why is ice in a glacier considers to be a mineral but water from a glacier is not?
Water is not considered a mineral because it does not meet the requirement of having a solid crystalline structure. Ice does meet this criterion and therefore, it is considered a mineral.
What mineral group is ice in?
Ice is in the mineral group known as "native elements." It is composed of the mineral water (H2O) in a solid-state.
Why is the ice in a glacier considered a mineral but the water in a river in not considered a mineral?
Ice in a glacier is considered a mineral because it has a crystalline structure formed by a naturally occurring inorganic substance (water) under specific conditions. In contrast, water in a river does not have a fixed crystalline structure or specific conditions for its formation, so it does not meet the criteria to be classified as a mineral.
How is water classified as a mineral?
Water cannot be classified as a mineral, ice can as long as its naturally occurring though so in some cases ice can but water may never because it is a liquid. And liquids can't be minerals because its not a solid. For mineral to be one is must be natural occurring, inorganic, solid, crystal structure, and definite chemical composition
When is water a mineral?
Water as a solid, in the form of ice, is considered a mineral when it is naturally occurring. Ice in snow banks is considered a mineral but ice cubes you make in your freezer are not a mineral.
When is water minerals?
Water as a solid, in the form of ice, is considered a mineral when it is naturally occurring. Ice in snow banks is considered a mineral but ice cubes you make in your freezer are not a mineral.
Why is ice in a glacier consider to be a mineral but water from a glacier is not?
By definition a mineral must be solid. Ice is solid. Water is not.
Can minerals be liquids?
No. A mineral must be solid to be a mineral. For example, liquid water is not a mineral. Frozen water, or ice, is a mineral.
Why is the ice in a glacier consider a mineral but the water in a river is not considered a mineral?
Ice in a glacier meets the requirements for being a mineral, because it is natural, homogeneous, solid and crystalline, and has a definite chemical fomula. River water is liquid and therefore also not crystalline, so it is not a mineral. If and when the river water freezes into ice (naturally), that ice is a mineral.
Why is the ice in glacier considered a mineral but the water in a river is not considered a mineral?
Ice in a glacier meets the requirements for being a mineral, because it is natural, homogeneous, solid and crystalline, and has a definite chemical fomula. River water is liquid and therefore also not crystalline, so it is not a mineral. If and when the river water freezes into ice (naturally), that ice is a mineral.
Is mineral ice a mineral?
Ice meets the criteria that define a mineral: solid, crystalline structure, definite chemical formula, naturally occuring, and inorganic. Ice is recognized as a mineral by the International Mineralogy Association.
Is water minerals or not?
Minerals are solid substances. Liquid water is not a mineral, but naturally occurring ice, is a mineral. The definition of a mineral requires it be naturally occurring so, artificially frozen ice in your freezer isn't a mineral.
Why is the ice in a glacier considered a mineral but the water in a river is not considered a mineral?
Ice in a glacier is solid and has a crystalline structure, meeting the criteria to be classified as a mineral. In contrast, water in a river is in liquid form and lacks a crystalline structure, so it does not meet the mineral criteria. The definition of a mineral specifies that it must be naturally occurring, inorganic, solid, have a crystalline structure, and a definite chemical composition, which ice but not liquid water fulfills.
Why is ice in a glacier considers to be a mineral but water from a glacier is not?
Water is not considered a mineral because it does not meet the requirement of having a solid crystalline structure. Ice does meet this criterion and therefore, it is considered a mineral.
Why is water ice considered a mineral?
Ice in a glacier is solid and has a definite chemical structure and water does not because water is liquid.
What mineral group is ice in?
Ice is in the mineral group known as "native elements." It is composed of the mineral water (H2O) in a solid-state.
