0
This is a copy of a summer project that I did for my school on why Truman should not have dropped the bomb, which I hope answers your question.
Dear President Truman:
As your most trusted advisor, and having explored all possible options, I have decided to strongly suggest that you NOT DROP the atomic bomb.
First and foremost, the bomb would kill millions of innocent people who do not care about the war. They have not provoked us in any way, and should not be harmed. These people do not participate in the war, even if they reluctantly send their fathers and husbands off to fight in the army. They are forced to do this by their government. The Japanese are not savage people, and should be considered a human being, just like everyone in the United States and the other countries.
Another reason to not drop the bomb is that we can avoid this, which I know you would prefer over dropping it. Through careful examination, I have come to the conclusion that we can show the Japanese what the bomb can do, just like we did in the test. Hopefully, they would surrender. They know that know we know how to build it, and we can make many more before they have a chance to strike.
A third and last reason for you not to drop the bomb is that it would deplete our stores of material, so we could not build any other thing, unless we raised the taxes very, very high. Making this bomb is very taxing on what we have in store, and I don't know how much will be left after it is dropped, if you decide it should be so. The people of the United States are sure to want you out of office if you raise the taxes. I'm sure that you'd like to be reelected for office, and this would make your chances of winning at about zero.
Truly, it would be a wise idea to not drop the atomic bomb for the reasons stated above.
Opinions on this issue vary widely. Some argue that dropping the atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki hastened the end of World War II, saving lives that would have been lost in a prolonged conflict. Others believe that the use of such a devastating weapon was morally questionable and that alternative options should have been pursued. Ultimately, whether Truman was right or not is subjective and depends on one's perspective on the ethical and strategic considerations involved.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why was nagasaki chosen as a site for the bombing of the atomic bomb?
Nagasaki was a target for the US to drop a Atomic Bomb in 1945. Reason for this is that it was one of the largest seaports in southern Japan, and was of great wartime importance because of its wide-ranging industrial activities, including the production of; ordnance, ships, military equipment, and other war materials.
Who opposed the Dropping of Atomic Bomb on Hiroshima Robert Oppenheimer or general Eisenhower?
General Eisenhower opposed the dropping of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima. He believed that Japan was already on the verge of surrender and that using the bomb was unnecessary and inhumane. Robert Oppenheimer, on the other hand, was one of the key scientists who helped develop the atomic bomb as part of the Manhattan Project.
What is an atomic winter?
An atomic winter is another term for a nuclear winter, a predicted drop in global temperature following a nuclear war due to dust in the upper atmosphere.
What cities in Japan did the US drop the atomic bombs?
The cities were called Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The US dropped the atomic bombs onto Japan on August 6th and 9th 1945.
Why does a bomber not drop its bomb vertically above the target?
Dropping the bomb at an angle allows the aircraft to safely release the bomb from a distance, reducing the risk of being hit by enemy defenses. Additionally, releasing the bomb at an angle helps to achieve better accuracy by taking into account factors like wind speed and trajectory.
What bomb did harry Truman drop?
Harry Truman drop the Atomic Bomb on Hiroshima, Japan and Nagasaki, Japan.
Who is the man who drop the atomic bomb on Japan?
President Truman.
Which president descided to use the atomic bomb against japan?
princess patrick harwood President Truman
Who orderded the drop of the atomic bomb on japan?
President Harry S. Truman
Who made the decisian to drop the atomic bomb on Japan?
Pres.Harry S. Truman .
Who decided to drop an atomic bomb on japan?
The US President Harry Truman.
Which US president decided to drop the atomic bomb?
President Harry Truman.
Which president called to drop atomic bomb on japan?
Harry S. Truman
Who decided to drop the atomic bomb and why?
Truman. The war needed to be ended ASAP!
What us leader Made thE decision to drop the atomic bomb in japan?
Truman
Why is Harry S. Truman famous?
He gave permission to drop the atomic bomb
What person commanded America to drop the atomic bomb on hiroshima?
President Truman
