0
Psalm 51 states explicitly when it was written: "When Nathan the prophet came to him" (to rebuke King David) in 2 Samuel ch.12.
What about the last two verses, which imply the lack of an altar and city walls?
Ibn Ezra commentary says that these verses may have been added later. Rashi commentary states that they refer to the Temple Mount, which had not yet been built in David's time (and which made Jerusalem what it was, a holy city). That is why the last verse mentions "Your altar," a title that would not apply to those altars that the Israelites had before the Temple was built. Metzudot commentary says that these verses were written by David, prophetically referring to the eventual exile (like Psalm 79).
Still curious? Ask our experts.
Chat with our AI personalities
Maxine
Judy
RenePsalm 51 was undoubtedly written during the dark years of the Babylonian Exile, centuries after the time of King David.
The exiled Jews believed that their condition was God's punishment for their sins, and much of Psalm 51 deals with repentance in the hope of a return (verse 14) to Judah. They also believed that they could not sacrifice to God in a foreign land, so verse 16 tells God that he does not desire a sacrifice but otherwise the author would offer one.
The psalm finishes with (verse 18) a plea to God to rebuild the walls of Jerusalem (a plea that David would not have needed to make) and then (verse 19) a promise that he would then offer bullocks in sacrifice on the altar of the Temple.
Psalm 51 could not have been written by David, whose city walls were intact and who could make burnt offerings whenever he chose.
Psalm 51 states explicitly when it was written: "When Nathan the prophet came to him" (to rebuke King David) in 2 Samuel ch.12.Link: The authorship of the Psalms
What about the last two verses, which imply the lack of an altar and city walls?
Ibn Ezra commentary says that these verses may have been added later.
Rashi commentary states that they refer to the Temple Mount, which had not yet been built in David's time (and which made Jerusalem what it was, a holy city). That is why the last verse mentions "Your altar," a title that would not apply to those altars that the Israelites had before the Temple was built.
Metzudot commentary says that these verses were written by David, prophetically referring to the eventual exile (like Psalm 79).
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Did King David write a prayer?
King David wrote the book of Psalms. Many of the Psalms are incorportated into the daily and sabbath prayers.
Did David write Psalms 119?
most scholars agree that it was written by David, Ezra, or Daniel.
King david was at what age when he wrote his 78 psalms?
King David was well in age when he wrote psalm78.
Which psalms did King David write in the Bible?
At one stage, all the Psalms were attributed to King David, but now only about 73 Psalms have superscriptions identifying him as the putative author. Even some of the Psalms still attributed to David clearly make historical references that must place them long after the tenth century BCE.Biblical scholars say that the Psalms were all written many centuries after the time of David.
Why did King David write the Book of Psalms?
A:Tradition attributes many of the Psalms to King David, although biblical scholars say he was quite unlikely to have contributed to any of the Psalms. In any case, Psalm 100 is not one of the Psalms said to have been written by David.Jewish answer:Jewish tradition is that all of the unnamed Psalms were authored by King David. Even Psalms with other authors are attributed to him, since he incorporated them into the canon of prayers and praises; otherwise they would likely have been lost.Psalms 100 is a Psalm of praise, which is what King David had in mind as its purpose. It was to be recited when ascending to the Holy Temple.
