answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

Probably not. But if the US had granted the Philippines immediate independence, there is little reason to believe they would have remained independent for long. Britain, Japan and Germany were all watching with great and greedy interest to see of the US would leave such a ripe and juicy plum as the Philippines lying on the table. All of these were openly "Empires" and in the business of expanding their respective Empires at every opportunity. US leadership was well aware of this state of affairs and the desirability of the Philippines to the Empires, and this was a major factor in the course the US followed.

User Avatar

Forrest Pfeffer

Lvl 10
3y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

11y ago

Probably not. But if the US had granted the Philippines immediate independence, there is little reason to believe they would have remained independent for long. Britain, Japan and Germany were all watching with great and greedy interest to see of the US would leave such a ripe and juicy plum as the Philippines lying on the table. All of these were openly "Empires" and in the business of expanding their respective Empires at every opportunity. US leadership was well aware of this state of affairs and the desirability of the Philippines to the Empires, and this was a major factor in the course the US followed.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Was the US justified in not granting immediate independence to the Philippines?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about General History

What debate almost prevented the Treaty of Paris from being ratified?

the debate about granting the Philippines independence


What country granted independence to the Philippines in 1898?

Spain A+ No country granted independence to the Philippines in 1898 although at least one group there declared them independent. Emilio Aguinaldo, a Filipino general, politician, and independence leader, declared Philippine independence from Spain in Kawit, Cavite on June 12, 1898 and the First Philippine Republic was established the following year. In the meantime the islands were ceded by Spain to the United States for US$20 million in the 1898 Treaty of Paris as a result of the Spanish-American War. The United States never recognized the First Philippine Republic and the Philippine-American War broke out. It ended with American control over the islands which were then administered as an insular area, so the Philippines passed from Spanish Colony to US posession without anyone granting them independence in between. In 1935, the Philippines was granted Commonwealth status. There were plans in the works to grant independence over the next 10 years, but they were disrupted when the Japanese Empire invaded during World War II. The US finally granted independence on July 4, 1946 after the end of the war.


Why were the Tea and Stamp acts important to the American Revolution?

by raising taxes in the American colonies without granting the colonies any representation in Parliament


What are the provisions of Tydings mcduffie?

1. The organization of constitutional Convention that draw up the fundamental law of the land. 2. The election of the leaders of Philippine Commonwealth 3. The recognition of Philippine independence on July 4, 1946. 4. The right of United States to establish military bases in the country 5. Granting the United States president the power to call on all military forces of the Philippines into service. 6. Reclassifying all Filipinos as aliens and limiting Immigration to the United Sates to 50 persons per year.


What was the technical term for granting a slave freedom in Roman times?

The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".The Latin word for granting a slave's freedom was/is "manumissio". In English it would be "manumission".

Related questions

What debate almost prevented the Treaty of Paris from being ratified?

the debate about granting the Philippines independence


How did the US respond to filipino demands for independence?

The US responded to Filipino demands for independence by granting the Philippines sovereignty on July 4, 1946, after decades of colonization. This came after the Philippines had endured a long struggle for self-governance and the recognition of their independence.


What reasons did McKinley argue that Philippines should not be granted their independence?

McKinley argued that the Philippines were not ready for self-government and needed American guidance to transition effectively. He believed that the Filipinos would not be able to govern themselves efficiently and may fall into chaos without US oversight. Additionally, he thought that granting independence too soon could endanger American strategic interests in the region.


Why did Helen hunt Jackson oppose the granting of immediate citizen to all Indians?

around the world it have things


What caused the Philippine insurrection in 1899?

the phollippines unsatisfaction with the us not granting them full independence


Why did the Filipino nationalist leader Emilio aguinaldo turn against the U.S. rule in the Philippines?

aguinaldo was angered when the united states decided to keep control of the Philippineshe was mad when the us wanted to keep control of it


What are the disadvantage and advantage of Japanese occupation here in the Philippines?

One advantage of Japanese occupation in the Philippines was the promotion of nationalist sentiments and the eventual granting of independence. However, the disadvantages included widespread human rights abuses, economic exploitation, and the loss of many lives through violent conflict and atrocities during World War II.


What did churchill call the postwar Soviet policy in eastern Europe?

evidence in granting India and Burma independence


What country granted independence to the Philippines in 1898?

Spain A+ No country granted independence to the Philippines in 1898 although at least one group there declared them independent. Emilio Aguinaldo, a Filipino general, politician, and independence leader, declared Philippine independence from Spain in Kawit, Cavite on June 12, 1898 and the First Philippine Republic was established the following year. In the meantime the islands were ceded by Spain to the United States for US$20 million in the 1898 Treaty of Paris as a result of the Spanish-American War. The United States never recognized the First Philippine Republic and the Philippine-American War broke out. It ended with American control over the islands which were then administered as an insular area, so the Philippines passed from Spanish Colony to US posession without anyone granting them independence in between. In 1935, the Philippines was granted Commonwealth status. There were plans in the works to grant independence over the next 10 years, but they were disrupted when the Japanese Empire invaded during World War II. The US finally granted independence on July 4, 1946 after the end of the war.


How many years now is the Filipino-American Friendship Day?

July 4, 2008 would be the 46th year of Phil-American Friendship Day. From 1946-1961, this day was celebrated as the Philippine Independence day based on the U.S. granting independence to the Philippines on July 4, 1946. In 1961, President Diosdado Macapagal changed Philippine Independence Day to June 12 based on the proclamation of independence by Gen. Emilio Aguinaldo on June 12, 1898. July 4th became the Phil-American Friendship day.


Last Europenan power to give up its African colonies?

It was Britain; it gave Zimbabwe independence in 1980. Ironically, Britain was also one of the first to begin decolonizing, granting Egypt independence in 1922


The Filipino rebellion against the US paved the way for the root?

The Filipino rebellion against the US, known as the Philippine-American War, began in 1899 and lasted until 1902. This rebellion challenged US colonial rule and sought independence for the Philippines. While the US ultimately suppressed the rebellion, it laid the groundwork for future resistance movements and eventually led to the granting of Philippine independence in 1946.