Do not rush it. Give the situation time to work itself out. If the situation could turn sour faster that you can come to a decision, then it is not a situation that would likely turn out well anyway.
Relationships like this can be stressful, but the best thing you can do is wait, until and unless you know exactly, beyond a doubt, who you want. Otherwise you will just be setting yourself and both girls up for a hard fall.
Chat with our AI personalities