answersLogoWhite

0

Were the Gospels written by the Disciples?

Updated: 10/31/2022
User Avatar

ManPerson

Lvl 1
13y ago

Best Answer

No. The New Testament gospels were written anonymously, and only later in the second century were they attributed to the disciples by Church Fathers.

In fact, the authors of the Gospels of Matthew and Luke are now known to have relied on Mark's Gospel for everything they knew about the life and mission of Jesus. John's Gospel, in turn, was inspired by Luke's Gospel, with a small amount of material taken direct from Mark. It is most improbable that disciples such as Matthew and John, said to be eyewitnesses to the life of Jesus, would need to rely so completely on the testimony of Mark, who even conservative Christians concede was not an eyewitness. Moreover, scholars say that the author of Mark's Gospel was not the Mark mentioned by the Apostle Paul.

We do not know who the anonymous authors of the gospels really were, but scholars say with confidence that they were not the disciples.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Were the Gospels written by the Disciples?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Continue Learning about Math & Arithmetic

Are any of the authors of 4 Gospels disciples of Jesus?

Matthew and John were disciples.


Who of the original twelve disciples wrote books of the Bible?

Christian tradition attributes the Gospels of Matthew and John to two of the twelve disciples. Epistles are also attributed to James, John, Jude and Peter.Actually, none of the twelve disciples wrote any book that we see in the New Testament. The four gospels were written anonymously and were only attributed th the disciples whose names they now bear, later in the second century. Scholars say that these gospels were not written by eyewitnesses to the events they portray. None of the epistles can be attributed to any of the disciples. In fact, Jude clearly identifies itself as a second-century book, while 2 Peter includes almost all of the material in Jude, proof that 2 Peter was also written during the second century. Scholars have looked closely at all these works to find evidence of the original disciples, but see nothing in the gospels or epistles that points back to any of the disciples.


What are the eyewitness accounts about Jesus called in the Bible?

Unfortunately there are no eyewitness accounts of the life or teachings of Jesus anywhere in the Bible or elsewhere. Even conservative Christians concede that the Gospels of Mark and Luke were not written by eyewitnesses. Scholars say that all the New Testament gospels were written anonymously and that they were not attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John until later in the second century. They say that the Gospels of Matthew and John were unlikely to have been written by the disciples of those names, so that even these gospels were not eyewitness accounts. The gospels are certainly accounts about Jesus, but they were not written by eyewitnesses or even by some who knew eyewitnesses.


How many Gospels were written?

Hundreds of gospels were written, but only 4 (Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, & John) were chosen to be in the Bible.


In what language were the gospels of the New Testament first written?

AnswerThe gospels of the New Testament were first written in Greek.

Related questions

Did eye witnesses write the four Gospels?

Matthew and John were written by eyewitnesses, Luke and Mark were written secondhand from disciples of Jesus.


Are any of the authors of 4 Gospels disciples of Jesus?

Matthew and John were disciples.


Who of the original twelve disciples wrote books of the Bible?

Christian tradition attributes the Gospels of Matthew and John to two of the twelve disciples. Epistles are also attributed to James, John, Jude and Peter.Actually, none of the twelve disciples wrote any book that we see in the New Testament. The four gospels were written anonymously and were only attributed th the disciples whose names they now bear, later in the second century. Scholars say that these gospels were not written by eyewitnesses to the events they portray. None of the epistles can be attributed to any of the disciples. In fact, Jude clearly identifies itself as a second-century book, while 2 Peter includes almost all of the material in Jude, proof that 2 Peter was also written during the second century. Scholars have looked closely at all these works to find evidence of the original disciples, but see nothing in the gospels or epistles that points back to any of the disciples.


Which two gospels were not written by one of Jesus' disciples?

A:All four New Testament gospels were originally anonymous and only attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John later in the second century. The gospel now known as John's Gospel was actually attributed to Cyrenthus before finally being attributes to John. The attributions to Matthew, Mark, Luke and Johnmean that Matthew and John were then considered to be witten by Jesus' disciples, while Mark and Luke were not.Modern New Testament scholars say that there is no good reason to accept the traditional attributions, and that none of the gospels could have been written by an eyewitness to the events portrayed. On this evidence, all the New Testament gospels were written by people who were not disciples.


Why did the other disciples of Jesus not write their gospel accounts of what Jesus did in their presence?

A:Over time, many of the disciples of Jesus were attributed gospels describing events associated with Jesus, either written anonymously or pseudepigraphically. The gospels that we know about included: Gospel of JamesThe Gospel of JohnGospel of JudasThe Gospel of LukeThe Gospel of MarkThe Gospel of MatthewThe Gospel of PeterThe Gospel of PhilipThe Gospel of ThomasIt is well established that none of the disciples actually wrote an eyewitness account, but many of the disciples were honoured with gospels in their names, including Matthew and John and several others.


Did the disciples suffer the costs of discipleship after the commission?

Most of them were martyred for preaching the gospels.


The two writers of the Gospels who were close followers or disciples of Christ were?

They were Matthew and John.


What do you think about the written report that we have from the eyewitnesses of Jesus?

A:Unfortunately there is no written report by any eyewitness to the life of Jesus anywhere in the Bible or elsewhere. Even conservative Christians concede that the Gospels of Mark and Luke were not written by eyewitnesses. Scholars say that all the New Testament gospels were written anonymously and that they were not attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John until later in the second century. They say that the Gospels of Matthew and John were unlikely to have been written by the disciples of those names, so that even these gospels were not eyewitness accounts. The gospels are certainly accounts about Jesus, whether reliable or otherwise, but they were not written by eyewitnesses or even by some who knew eyewitnesses.


What were the accomplishments of St Matthew?

Matthew was one of the lesser known disciples mentioned in the gospels. Matthew is traditionally associated with one of the New Testament gospels, but the gospel was originally anonymous and biblical scholars say that it could not really have been written by Matthew.


What are the eyewitness accounts about Jesus called in the Bible?

Unfortunately there are no eyewitness accounts of the life or teachings of Jesus anywhere in the Bible or elsewhere. Even conservative Christians concede that the Gospels of Mark and Luke were not written by eyewitnesses. Scholars say that all the New Testament gospels were written anonymously and that they were not attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John until later in the second century. They say that the Gospels of Matthew and John were unlikely to have been written by the disciples of those names, so that even these gospels were not eyewitness accounts. The gospels are certainly accounts about Jesus, but they were not written by eyewitnesses or even by some who knew eyewitnesses.


Did Philip write a book of the Bible?

Philip is listed as one of the twelve disciples but as far as we know , none of the disciples wrote anything. The four New Testament gospels were originally anonymous and were not written by any of the disciples, in spite of second-century attributions. There is a non-canonical Gospel of Philip but it was, like the canonical gospels, originally anonymous; in any case it is generally believed to have been written after 150 CE. This means that not only did Philip not write a book of the Bible, he also probably did not even write a book outside the Bible.


Which book of the Bible tells us of the adventures of the disciples of Jesus?

The gospels (Matthew, Mark, Luke and John) tell the story oof Jesus and his disciples.. However, the Book of Acts (also written by Luke) tells the account of what the disciples did after th death, resurrection and ascension of Jesus, and also tells of Paul's journeys establishing the Church across the Mediterranean area.