answersLogoWhite

0

Does photoreading work

Updated: 9/11/2023
User Avatar

Wiki User

16y ago

Best Answer

In January of 2000 Dr. Danielle S. McNamara submitted a preliminary report to the NASA Ames Research Center on photoreading. McNamara enrolled in a PhotoReading workshop under the tutelage of an expert who, in three years, had trained about 150 individuals in PhotoReading. The trainee spent two months learning the PhotoReading technique. The two participants named in the study were "(a) the PhotoReading trainee who participated ina two-day photoreading workshop, and (b) the photoreading expert who provided the PhotoReading workshop." (McNamara 4). The study design included two normal pretests, followed by parallel versions of five reading tests employing the PhotoReading technique. One test was the Nelson Reading Comprehension Test (forms G and H) and the Verbal Reasoning section of the MCAT. The other two tests were generated by the experimenter. This study tests only difficult expository texts because "PhotoReading has been claimed to be particularly effective for this type of text" (McNamara 5). The texts used here involve subjects like physiology, perception, and Biology. Each question from these texts were generated around a single idea or sentence within each text. According to McNamara "The information in the text that is targeted by the question generally requires little prior knowledge and little active processing of the text to understand" (McNamara 6). The results of the study generally follow the pattern that PhotoReading and normal reading require a similar amount of time to complete. For example, the expert scored 37 of 38 possible questions correct with normal reading taking 19.43 minutes to do so. Then the expert took a similar test after PhotoReading the passage and scored a 38 out of 38 possible questions correct in a time of 18.13 minutes. McNamara took the same test, and scored a 92% both times. However, photoreading took 21.30 minutes whereas regular reading took 15.80 minutes. These results show that photoreading can work, but they do not support the 25,000 words per minute claims. In a text about perception, the expert took 8.82 minutes to read the text using normal reading. Then, he photoread the text in 0.87 minutes and proceeded to read the text for another 8.12 minutes before he completed the process. In the text involving normal reading he answered three questions correctly out of eight. Photoreading, he scored only 1 out of 8 correctly. These results do not support assertions that Photoreading help one study faster and with greater comprehension than with ordinary reading techniques. To conclude the study, McNamara noted that, "In terms of words per minute (wpm) spent reading, there was no difference between normal reading (M = 114 wpm) and PhotoReading (M=112 wpm)" (10). So why is it that so many people tout photoreading? In her conclusion, McNamara states that, "One aspect of the PhotoReading technique is that it leaves the reader with a false sense of confidence." (12).

User Avatar

Wiki User

16y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Does photoreading work
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

PhotoReading course in Columbus Ohio?

My name is Benjamin and I want to take the PhotoReading course in Columbus Ohio. See attached link


How does the Photoreading program increase reading speed?

Photoreading uses a five step process to help the eyes and the brain read more quickly. The intention is to use one's eyes to scan a whole page to find the content the user is particularly looking for, and to use the memory to bring back this information more easily.


How did African slaves get education?

They got their education by secretly learning it if their master didn't allowed because it was illegal. Sometimes, their masters tought the slave even though it was against the law. By secretly learning it, they could learn it off another slave or steal a book and educate themselves.


How do tosters work?

they just work they just work,work,work


The work you do on a machine is called work?

the work a machine does is the work outputwhat it takes to do the work is the work inputSources;The_work_that_the_simple_machine_does_is_called_the_work


The work that the simple machine does is called the work?

the work a machine does is the work output what it takes to do the work is the work input


If a Mexican were to come and live in the US what do they do here?

Work , Work , Work , Work , Work , Work ! They do what You lazy Americans don't . Mexicans work hard . They do it all !


What is a work calendar?

A calendar at your work, for your work, that has your work schedule on it, etc.


What is the verb in you work late?

The verb in "you work late" is "work."


Will American cd's work in Australia?

Yes it can work Yes it can work Yes it can work Yes it can work


What is the differences between work input and work output?

Work Output is the work done BY a machine. Work Input is the work done ON a machine.


What is the difference between work input and work output?

Work Output is the work done BY a machine. Work Input is the work done ON a machine.