0
Did Andrew Jackson ignore John Marshall's order in Worcester v. Georgia?
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
No. President Jackson ignored John Marshall's personal opinion about the federal government owing protection to the Cherokee, but that wasn't part of the official ruling in Worcester because the United States was not a party to the case. Courts only have authority to issue legally binding decisions against people or entities named as a party to the suit being tried. Jackson may have had a moral and ethical obligation to defend the Cherokee Nation against Georgia's aggression, but no legal duty had been established.
The only legal rulings in the case were against the state of Georgia. Under pressure from President Jackson, the Governor of Georgia complied with the order to release the plaintiffs, but ignored the opinion about the state's lack of rights with regard to both the Cherokee and their territory. The President declined to intervene.
Jackson continued to support Georgia in its mission to drive the Native Americans from their land, and successfully hobbled Marshall by nominating like-minded Associate Justices to vacancies on the then seven-member court. By politicizing the Court, Jackson subverted its power as one of the checks and balances on the Executive and Legislative branches.
The sad conclusion to this story was the 1836 ratification of a removal treaty between the United States government and the Cherokee Nation, the Treaty of New Echota. This resulted in the US Army forcibly relocating the Native Americans from their ancestral land under the Van Buren administration in 1838, a travesty later known as The Trail of Tears.
Case Citation:
Worcester v. Georgia, 31 US 515 (1832)
For more information, see Related Questions, below.
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
Wiki User
∙ 12y agoHe felt the decision could not be enforced.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Who was president during worcester v georgia?
President Andrew Jackson.
Why did John Marshall strongly oppose Andrew Jackson?
In the court case Worcester v. Georgia, Marshall ruled that Jackson's Indian Removal Act was unconstitutional and that he should abolish it immediately. Jackson said, "John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it!" and completely ignored Marshall's orders. This caused hatred between the two men.
Who was the American leader at the battle of new Orleans?
Andrew Jackson
How did manifest destiny affect Texas?
Andrew Jackson won the election Andrew Jackson won the election Andrew Jackson won the election Andrew Jackson won the election Andrew Jackson won the election Andrew Jackson won the election Andrew Jackson won the election
Who Supported the the Indian removal act?
Andrew Jackson
Who was president during worcester v georgia?
President Andrew Jackson.
How did Andrew Jackson respond to the Supreme Court decision in Worcester V Georgia?
Yes he did
Did Andrew Jackson and the State of Georgia obeyed the Supreme Court ruling in Cherokee v Georgia?
no
Did john marshall like Andrew Jackson?
No, John Marshall did not like Andrew Jackson. Marshall was a staunch Federalist and believed in a strong central government, while Jackson was a Democratic-Republican who favored state power and opposed the Supreme Court's authority. Additionally, Jackson famously disregarded Marshall's rulings in cases such as Worcester v. Georgia, leading to strained relations between the two.
What Supreme Court decision did president Jackson ignore?
Jackson ignored Worcester v. Georgia. This was significant because Andrew Jackson ignored the Supreme Court's decision which said that Georgia couldn't make laws that broke the terms on the authority of which the Cherokee's have the right to govern themselves on. Many people ask can he ignore the Supreme Court? Or, Why didn't the Supreme Court do anything about it? And do you know what I would say. idk. :)
Why did John Marshall strongly oppose Andrew Jackson?
In the court case Worcester v. Georgia, Marshall ruled that Jackson's Indian Removal Act was unconstitutional and that he should abolish it immediately. Jackson said, "John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it!" and completely ignored Marshall's orders. This caused hatred between the two men.
How did Andrew Jackson defy the supreme court?
Although he was a good general, he was not very experienced at being president. He once quoted him self: "I would rather be right then be president". He defied the Supreme Court order by publishing the Indian Removal Act. This act pushed them out of their originally settling places and back even more. Andrew Jackson defied a Supreme Court order who said it was unconstitutional from the start. He resigned before he was officially impeached.
Why did president Monroe send Andrew Jackson to Georgia?
Andrew Jackson was sent to Georgia to chase a tribe of Seminole Indians back into Florida who had been raiding and damaging plantations because there were no rich people or plantations in the Spain territory of Florida.
Soon after jackson took office what state claimed the right to seize cherokee lands?
It wasn't a state, but the federal government under president Andrew Jackson.
What main impact did Andrew Jackson have on the geography of the southern states?
Adding territory to Florida and Georgia was one way Andrew Jackson impacted the geography of the southern states. Jackson also added territory to Alabama.
What church do Andrew Jackson Young attend?
Andrew Jackson was a Presbyterian. He was born into a Presbyterian and raised as a Presbyterian.But he did not officially join the Presbyterian Church until after his he left the chair as president
What was the law president Andrew Jackson used to get around the Supreme Courts desicion?
Georgia Law
